This is the mail archive of the
mailing list for the eCos project.
RE: Copyright Assignment from Altera Corp.
- From: "Elaine Lee" <ELEE at altera dot com>
- To: "Jonathan Larmour" <jifl at ecoscentric dot com>,"eCos Maintainers" <ecos-maintainers at ecos dot sourceware dot org>
- Cc: "Iain Scott" <ISCOTT at altera dot com>,"Paul Riley" <PRILEY at altera dot com>, <Andrew at lunn dot ch>
- Date: Wed, 19 Jan 2005 08:53:08 -0800
- Subject: RE: Copyright Assignment from Altera Corp.
Your changes to the Altera open source Assignment of Copyright form are
acceptable to Altera. I will send you two originals executed by Altera
to the address listed in http://ecos.sourceware.org/assign.html. Upon
receipt, please have both originals executed by your signatory and
return one original to me at the address listed below.
Thanks very much for your help!
101 Innovation Drive M/S 1405
San Jose, CA 95134 USA
Phone +1 408 544 7591
Fax +1 408 544 8304
From: Jonathan Larmour [mailto:email@example.com]
Sent: Thursday, January 13, 2005 3:46 PM
To: Elaine Lee; eCos Maintainers
Cc: Iain Scott; Paul Riley
Subject: Re: Copyright Assignment from Altera Corp.
> To: Andrew@lunn.ch, firstname.lastname@example.org
> Cc: Iain Scott <ISCOTT@altera.com>, Paul Riley <PRILEY@altera.com>
> Hello Andrew and eCos maintainers,
> I am writing regarding a contribution of computer software source code
> Altera Corporation will be making to eCos, subject to execution of a
> copyright assignment agreement between Altera and eCos. I believe
> Scott and Paul Riley of Altera has been in contact with Andrew Lunn
> about this contribution.
Andrew asked me to look at the assignment text, and I discussed with and
passed it over to the eCosCentric CEO for comments on the legal aspects.
> The contribution relates to a port of the eCos operating system for
> II, and drivers for various SOPC Builder peripherals. I have reviewed
> your web pages regarding contributing to eCos and copyright
> Altera has a standard Assignment of Copyright for open source and
> freeware computer software, which is attached. I believe this
> Assignment addresses the points brought up in eCos' copyright
> language and description.
There are a few subtle differences that mean we can't use the exact text
you supplied straight off I'm afraid.
1) First of all the definition of "Works" and separately clause 7 refer
code checked into the Assignee's source code repository by Altera. That
isn't the way it works with eCos (especially since the Assignee doesn't
manage the relevant repository!). Something along the lines of "posted
the email@example.com mailing list or via the eCos
web site" would be more appropriate.
2) Secondly, the normal eCos license consists of the GNU General Public
License (GPL), but also an exception to some of the terms of the GPL
<http://ecos.sourceware.org/license-overview.html>). Clause 4 has
with the exception part which is written to intentionally permit derived
works where the only source code that must be given out is that of eCos
itself, and not the application to which it is linked (despite the whole
being a derived work).
As such we think the best solution is for clause 4 to be amended so that
the mentions of the "the work" from the 4th, 5th, and 7th lines of
would become "the Works".
3) Similarly for clause 5: 'any program "based on the Works"' should
instead be replaced by 'the Program "based on the Works"'
With those changes, the assignment would suit our needs and be
with the eCos license.
However if you find it easier to just go with the normal assignment at
<http://ecos.sourceware.org/assign.html>, then that's fine too.
Hope this helps and thanks for contributing back!
eCosCentric http://www.eCosCentric.com/ The eCos and RedBoot
--["No sense being pessimistic, it wouldn't work anyway"]--